Friday, November 22, 2013

Intersex Aggression in Dobermans

A big huge flag in the Doberman community is when a male puppy is sold to people with another male dog in the household already. Why?

Well, the stories say that Dobermans can be same sex aggressive. Two males, two females, there is a chance that when the second dog reaches sexual maturity (or both dogs, if you're making the equally dubious choice to raise them together), there is a chance that the dogs will become aggressive to members of the same sex and want to fight.

This is problematic, as we do not typically want dogs to fight. Not unless you're a scumbag.





Now, since it's mentioned on the Doberman Pinscher Club of America web site, and an "aggressive or belligerent attitude towards other dogs" is not a DQ in the AKC ring, I thought it was accepted knowledge and recorded somewhere, scientifically, that Dobermans can be same sex aggressive. This does not mean they will be, nor will always be, etc. etc. But that it can happen.

Wouldn't you know I can't find anything on it? Not really. Not to my satisfaction. There's a wealth of information on Doberman Talk, of people discussing their experience with males turning same sex aggressive at sexual maturity (2 or 3 or so), regardless of whether they're subsequently neutered, the other male dogs are neutered, etc. "Crate and rotate" is something that many houses are familiar with, because they absolutely cannot trust their male dogs together, supervised or not. And these are people who have been in Dobermans for years, decades. Who train and socialize. Who buy from reputable breeders who title their dogs.

So why no studies?

I found other studies, other things that mention same sex aggression in dogs. But not Dobermans, or really any other breed by name. But I've found Dobermans mentioned as a same sex aggression candidate in other places on the web than just Doberman Talk. It was in a Yahoo! answer. It was on a German Shepherd message board. So people know. There just isn't "literature". It's rather frustrating.

This article on Canine aggression mentions it in "types of aggression". The RSPCA has an FAQ on canine aggression, which includes topics such as "if I neuter my dog, will the aggression go away?" I found somebody's Master's thesis on "Management and Rehabilitation of Inter-Dog Aggression in Animal Shelters". I found an article on Canis Major about dogs fighting. I found a presentation, with powerpoint slides, on "Scientific research studies that found spaying and neutering do not reduce aggression in dogs". And last but not least "The Effects of Spaying and Neutering on Canine Behavior".

I really want "my Doberman people" to be right. They are the voice of experience, and I pretty much trust them (many of them, anyway) as the Voice of Experience on Doberman things. I came in a total novice, and I've learned a lot from them, and learned what to look for and what questions to ask when furthering my research.

But especially when trying to educate somebody online (or at the very least, when trying to present a reasonable point of view when you feel they are perhaps not making the best decisions), you want to be able to cite sources. Not just say "so and so said and so did Bob". I do not like handing out incorrect information, but it can't be "proven" correct without citations, you know? Citations or no, I feel all of these peoples' experiences are valuable information, and as I said, to be trusted. But somebody determined to be right whose views differ are obviously not going to see it that way.

Sometimes they don't want to see it any way and they're really just trolling after all, and it's a situation like that which sparked this post but.....it's still food for thought.

8 comments:

  1. That is really interesting. I have heard that said about all breeds, but know it's not true. I never knew it about Dobermans
    Lily

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, it's really hard to sort out what "breed specific" aggressions there are and aren't. I guess people do say "in general" males won't get along, and it isn't a bad rule of thumb. Obviously, though, all dogs are still individual.

      Delete
  2. Many dog people preach the gospel that dogs are more likely to be aggressive with other dogs of the same gender. I'd love to see a careful study on this. But it may just be one of those things "everybody knows" that just isn't true.

    Aleksandra of Love and a Leash kept on getting female fosters because she already had a male at home. Her pittie, Chick, never got along with any of the girls. One time they got a male foster dog and Chick fell in love. They adopted him and never looked back.

    Dogs are such individuals. They are more than their breed. They are more than their gender. I think the best thing is to know your dog and watch her behavior carefully before deciding what kind of new dog to bring into your home.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I love Love and Leash! I was so happy when they adopted the Dude because he and Chick got along so well.

      Strangely, one of the studies I saw was aggression in Golden Retrievers, who I guess have "reverse prejudice"; everybody assumes they'll be friendly!

      I think individual differences are the main thing to keep focus on.

      Delete
  3. Well, I know that we don't take Küster to a lot of places because he isn't neutered and a lot of male dogs have a problem with unneutered males (and some females do at times, too), but I hadn't heard of it as a breed specific thing to any one breed. It is kind of odd that there's no study published on it, but it might be one of those things that's been passed along for so long that everyone just sort of assumes it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There are a lot of hearsay things that we think are ridiculous now, and others that might be true but seem to have no science behind them. It can be very frustrating!

      Delete
  4. My girl is same-sex hateful. I prefer not to say aggressive, because there are occasionally other females that she doesn't detest. She is a Malamute mix, and Malamutes are also known for this. This is also the reason she is my only girl, with two boys.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I didn't know Malamutes are known for it (though I know very little about Malamutes....). I think "hateful" makes sense, since it isn't an every time thing.

      Delete